Directed by: Guillermo del Toro
Premise: At the end of World War II, Ofeila (Ivana
Baquero) and her mother (Ariadna Gil) move to a camp to be with her new
step-father (Sergi López), a fascist army captain. While in the camp, Ofelia
enters a fantasy world of a faun (Doug Jones) who may or may not be real.
What Works: The film merges fantasy and reality in
very successful ways, muddling the two and keeping the audience engaged. Whether
the fantasy is real or not is itself interesting and the implications of the
fantasy and Ofelia's use of it to escape from her vicious step-father, are very
remarkable and give the viewer more substance to work with than the average
fantasy film. The fantasy visions of the piece are quite well done and have a
more mature look to them than some other picture; the scenes are not overdone
and have an old school Brothers Grimm quality that makes them more palatable.
What Doesn’t: The characters of the film do not
have much flair to them. Unlike the children of films like Harry Potter or The
Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, Ofelia does
not have the kind of character dynamic that would make her interesting to watch.
Bottom Line: Guillermo del Toro is quickly emerging
as one of the great director’s of his generation and a great asset to the
fantasy genre at a time when it is being diluted by films like Eragon that have only a superficial understanding of the implications and possibilities
of the genre. Despite some of the flaws in characterization, the film is still
very impressive and ranks as one of the better fantasy films in recent years.